User experience with Drop In Filters

Okay, so I am looking at these dry drop in filters.
Im in a toss up between the Rugged Ridge for $55 CAD and the aFe one for about $79 CAD both on Amazon.

Who has had experience with either and what do you recommend.

Note: I am just looking for a filter that will allow me to re-use it, I don’t expect any MPG gain or performance gain, but if I do.. great!

Please enlighten me

Salty Soul Jeep Shirt

Article source: